Response:

Good question. The answer appears to be, both from the words used and the response of the angel, that Zacherias was motivated by unbelief, while Mary was motivated by an interest in how this would be accomplished. Two different Greek words are used. Zacherias begins his question with the word "kata", which often carries with it an idea of opposition, while Mary begins her's with "pros", which does not carry that idea at all. Zacherias, in his unbelief that the angel he is talking to has brought him an answer to his prayers, asks for a sign, and he gets it: he is struck dumb, and quite possibly deaf as well (vs 62). Mary, on the other hand, asks how this miracle that she believes will happen, and the angel tells her in verse 35.

I guess this would be similar to having a child or student respond to your instructions by asking "Why?". Some questions are asked because the child has a genuine desire to receive more knowledge. Other questions are raised because the child is questioning your authority to give the directive. The first type of question is answered with more information and explanation. The second type of question is answered by discipline.

By Dr Mark Montgomery Ambassador Baptist Church 1926 Babcock Blvd Pittsburgh, PA 15209 (412)477-3210